Skip to main content

One of the many joys of modern life is that yummy treats are just a couple of clicks away. In honor of the arrival of autumn, we’ve rounded up the 10 best Fall desserts to buy right now via mail order.

The 10 Best Fall Desserts to Buy Right Now Via Mail Order

Fall is almost here – in fact, it’s so close we can taste it. And since we don’t want to wait until the actual equinox to get a jump on all things fall, we’re filling our fridges with everything we need to bring the season to us.

More than any other season, fall is full of flavor. After all, autumn is the season of the harvest, and we want to taste its many splendors all season long.  Maple. Cinnamon. Caramel. And of course, good old pumpkin spice.

If you’ve thinking along the same lines, we have some suggestions for you. Some special fall treats you can order right now, in order to bring the season right to your door. We’ve got pumpkin spice, we’ve got caramel apple, and yes – we’ve got some spook-tacular Halloween snacks for you as well.

Here are the ten mail-order treats you need to get a delicious head start on the best time of the year.

The 10 Best Fall Desserts to Buy Right Now Via Mail Order

1. Pumpkin Maple Cinnamon Bundt Cake

It’s fall in cake-form. We Take the Cake lives up to their name – they can take care of any cake for any occasion, and leave you wanting a second slice – and we have fallen head over heels for their seasonal special. This freshly-baked bundt cake is made with pumpkin puree, seasoned with allspice and cinnamon, and drizzled in a gooey and delicious maple cinnamon cream cheese frosting. If you want to taste the whole season in one single bite, this is the autumn treat for you.

Pumpkin Maple Cinnamon Bundt Cake by We Take the Cake

The best Fall desserts to buy online via mail order including cookies, cupcakes, cakes, and more.

BUY NOW – $45.95.

2. Colossal Caramel Apples

If the words “colossal caramel apple” didn’t pique your interest… we don’t know what to tell you. From Savannah’s Candy Kitchen, these apples are the size of softballs – yes, really – and they blend the refreshing tartness of a Granny Smith apple with the creamy sweetness of caramel, the salty crunch of pecans, and a perfect little pop of chocolate. These aren’t the caramel apples you had as a kid – they’re ten times better. Perfect as a gift, or for you to enjoy yourself.

Colossal Caramel Apples by Savannah's Candy Kitchen

The best Fall desserts to buy online via mail order including cookies, cupcakes, cakes, and more.

BUY NOW – $79.95.

3. Pillsbury Ready to Bake Sugar Cookies

There’s a reason these familiar-looking Pillsbury cookies are a classic for the season. Though they may seem ubiquitous, they can be weirdly hard to find – supermarkets sell out in minutes, and you can’t even order them on Amazon – but Acme Markets has them available to ship. These cookies are something you should always have on hand, for any last-minute Halloween-related emergencies.

Pillsbury Ready To Bake Pumpkin Shape Sugar Cookie Dough 20 Count - 9.1 OZ

The best Fall desserts to buy online via mail order including cookies, cupcakes, cakes, and more.

BUY NOW – $3.79.

4. Signature Salted Caramel Apple Pie

Sometimes, when a specific dish is talked about too much, it can’t possibly live up to its reputation. Well, this is not a problem for the internet’s favorite pie. Four and Twenty Blackbirds’ creations are even better than everyone says, and their signature salted caramel apple is the best of the best. The is a truly epic fall dessert, and one that lives up to all the hype. And what is the season without a slice of apple pie?

Signature Salted Caramel Apple Pie by Four & Twenty Blackbirds

The best Fall desserts to buy online via mail order including cookies, cupcakes, cakes, and more.

BUY NOW – $84.95.

5. Pumpkin Shaped Cake

If you’re hosting any kind of festive get-together this fall, you might want to consider springing for this spectacular five-layer pumpkin-shaped cake. You’ll get layers of cozy pumpkin spice cake sandwiched between tangy cream cheese frosting, and decorated with green and orange fondant Every cake is decorated by hand, and can serve up to fifteen people. This is how to start the season off right.

Alt image 2 for Five-Layer Pumpkin Shaped Cake, Serves 15

The best Fall desserts to buy online via mail order including cookies, cupcakes, cakes, and more.

BUY NOW – $189.95.

6. Hallow’s Eve Bark

Of course, Halloween candy always comprises a large part of our autumn diet. But sometimes, those third and fourth snickers bars do leave us feeling a little sick – and a little like we’re six. That’s why we love this Hallow’s Eve Chocolate Bark from Williams-Sonoma. It’s scarily festive – complete with googly eyes, sugar bones, and a delicate sprinkling of candy corn – as well as delicious, and it feels like the grown-up version of a Halloween candy haul. You can snack all season long, or serve at your Halloween party.

Alt image 1 for Hallow's Eve Chocolate Bark

The best Fall desserts to buy online via mail order including cookies, cupcakes, cakes, and more.

BUY NOW – $34.00.

7 Fall Cupcake Jar Six-Pack

If you’re hoping to send fall treats to someone as a gift, might we suggest these cupcake jars from Wicked Good Cupcakes? This six-pack is designed to travel well, and to offer a flight of all your favorite fall flavors. We’ve got pumpkin spice, chocolate hazelnut, hot cocoa, mocha, s’mores, and caramel apple streusel. It can be hard to pick which fall dessert is your favorite, and now you – or the person you’re gifting – doesn’t have to choose. And yes, the cupcakes really are wicked good.

Fall Cupcake 6-Pack

The best Fall desserts to buy online via mail order including cookies, cupcakes, cakes, and more.

BUY NOW – $69.99.

8. Buttercream Frosted Halloween Cookies

These cookies spark joy. So much of the fun of fall is getting to the things that are as adorable (and spooky!) as they are delicious. And these buttercream-frosted cookies from Cheryl’s more than fit the bill. Invite these pumpkins and ghosts to your fall table, without having to worry about whether you yourself did the frosting design right. You can order between 12 and 200 cookies, so even the biggest parties will be fully fed.

Buttercream Frosted Pumpkin Cut Out Cookies

The best Fall desserts to buy online via mail order including cookies, cupcakes, cakes, and more.

BUY NOW -$29.99 – $249.99.

The 10 Best Fall Desserts to Buy Right Now Via Mail Order

Cookies, cupcakes, layer cakes and more – whatever your fall favorite is, you’ll find it here. Enjoy! And save us a slice.

Pamela Thomas-Graham

Pamela Thomas-Graham is the Founder & CEO of Dandelion Chandelier. She serves on the boards of several tech companies, and was previously a senior executive in finance, media and fashion, and a partner at McKinsey & Co.